Topology Optimization Design of Aero-engine External System Brackets for Additive Manufacturing

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-132X.2022.23.006

Abstract

Abstract: The mechanics properties of aero-engine external system supports under critical loading conditions were analyzed. The support smoothness under two kinds of ultimate load conditions was used as objective function. The topology optimization design and performance check of external system supports for additive manufacturing were conducted using transverse isotropic model of additive manufacturing materials. The results of the mechanics test of metal laser additive manufacturing samples shows that， compared with the initial structure， the support design for additive manufacturing has a 15% less material usage， the stiffness increases by about 20%， and the first-order natural frequency improves by 15%. The structural strength increases significantly. The integrated additive manufacturing with 1 external system support， 2 piping supports and 4 rivets was realized herein， which effectively improves the quality and efficiency of engine assembly. The ground static load and engine ignition tests were successfully passed.

Key words: , topology optimization, variable density method, external system bracket, multiple loading condition, additive manufacturing

摘要： 分析了严酷载荷工况下航空发动机外部系统支架的力学性能，以两种极限载荷工况下的支架柔顺度为目标函数，采用增材制造材料横观各向同性模型，开展了面向增材制造的外部系统支架拓扑优化设计与性能校核。金属激光增材制造样件的力学试验表明：面向增材制造的支架设计较初始结构质量减小约15%，刚度增大约20%，一阶固有频率提高约15%，结构强度显著增大。该方案实现了1个外部系统支架、2个管路支架和4颗铆钉的一体化增材制造，有效提升了发动机装配质量和效率，顺利通过地面静载和发动机点火试验。

关键词: 拓扑优化, 变密度法, 外部系统支架, 多载荷工况, 增材制造

CLC Number:

V232.7

MENG Liang, ZHONG Mingzhe, LI Wenbiao, XIA Liang, GAO Tong, ZHU Jihong, ZHANG Weihong, . Topology Optimization Design of Aero-engine External System Brackets for Additive Manufacturing[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2822-2832.

孟亮, 仲明哲, 李文彪, 夏凉, 高彤, 朱继宏, 张卫红, . 面向增材制造的航空发动机外部系统支架拓扑优化设计[J]. 中国机械工程, 2022, 33(23): 2822-2832.

References

［1］唐术. 基于加工、装配与维护的航空发动机外部系统设计研究［D］. 成都：电子科技大学， 2009.
TANG Shu. Research on Design of Aero-engine External System Based on Machining， Assembly and Maintenance［D］. Chengdu：University of Electronic Science and Technology of China， 2009.
［2］朱继宏，李军朔，张卫红，等. 现代形状优化技术在航空发动机零部件设计中的应用［J］. 航空制造技术， 2012， 55（23/24）：30-35.
ZHU Jihong， LI Junshuo， ZHANG Weihong， et al. Applications of Advanced Shape Optimization Technology in Structural Design of Aeroengine［J］. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology， 2012， 55（23/24）：30-35.
［3］CHEN L， ZHANG W， MENG L， et al. An Adaptive T-spline Finite Cell Method for Structural Shape Optimization［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2020， 61（5）：1857-1876.
［4］FENG S， ZHANG W， MENG L， et al. Stiffener Layout Optimization of Shell Structures with B-spline Parameterization Method［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2021， 63（6）：2637-2651.
［5］TANG L， GAO T， SONG L， et al. Topology Optimization of Nonlinear Heat Conduction Problems Involving Large Temperature Gradient［J］. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering， 2019， 357：112600.
［6］LI Y， GAO T， ZHOU Q Y， et al. Layout Design of Thin-walled Structures with Lattices and Stiffeners Using Multi-material Topology Optimization［J/OL］. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics， 2022［2022-08-26］. https：∥doi. org/10. 1016/j. cja. 2022. 07. 022.
［7］ZHANG Z J， ZHANG R T， ZHU J H， et al. Integrated Batteries Layout and Structural Topology Optimization for a Solar-powered Drone［J］. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics， 2021， 34（7）：114-123.
［8］XIE Y M， STEVEN G P. A Simple Evolutionary Procedure for Structural Optimization［J］. Computers & Structures， 1993， 49（5）：885-896.
［9］LI X， GAO L， ZHOU Y， et al. A Hybrid Level Set Method for the Integrated Optimization of Structural Topology and Multicomponent Layout［J］. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering， 2021， 122（11）：2802-2828.
［10］MENG L， ZHANG W H， ZHU J H， et al. Shape Optimization of Axisymmetric Solids with the Finite Cell Method Using a Fixed Grid［J］. Acta Mechanica Sinica， 2016， 32（3）：510-524.
［11］CAI S Y， ZHANG W H， GAO T， et al. Adaptive Bubble Method Using Fixed Mesh and Topological Derivative for Structural Topology Optimization［J］. Chinese Journal of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics， 2019， 51（4）：1235-1244.
［12］GAO J， XIAO M， ZHANG Y， et al. A Comprehensive Review of Isogeometric Topology Optimization：Methods， Applications and Prospects［J］. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2020， 33（6）：24-37.
［13］ZHANG W， JIU L， MENG L. Buckling-constrained Topology Optimization Using Feature-driven Optimization Method［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2022， 65：37.
［14］SHI G H， GUAN C Q， QUAN D L， et al. An Aerospace Bracket Designed by Thermo-elastic Topology Optimization and Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing［J］. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics， 2020， 33（4）：1252-1259.
［15］ZHU J H， ZHANG W H， XIA L. Topology Optimization in Aircraft and Aerospace Structures Design［J］. Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering， 2016， 23（4）：595-622.
［16］JANKOVICS D， BARARI A. Customization of Automotive Structural Components Using Additive Manufacturing and Topology Optimization［J］. IFAC-PapersOnLine， 2019， 52（10）：212-217.
［17］JEWETT J L， CARSTENSEN J V. Topology-optimized Design， Construction and Experimental Evaluation of Concrete Beams［J］. Automation in Construction， 2019， 102：59-67.
［18］ZHENG Y H， WANG Y C， CHEN R K， et al. Tissue Transformation Mold Design and Stereolithography Fabrication［J］. Rapid Prototyping Journal， 2017， 23（1）：162-168.
［19］BUTLER J. Using Selective Laser Sintering for Manufacturing［J］. Assembly Automation， 2011， 31（3）：212-219.
［20］KRUTH J P， FRO YEN L， VAN VAERENBERGH J， et al. Selective Laser Melting of Iron-based Powder［J］. Journal of Materials Processing Technology， 2004， 149（1/3）：616-622.
［21］TAYLOR A C， BEIRNE S， ALICI G， et al. System and Process Development for Coaxial Extrusion in Fused Deposition Modelling［J］. Rapid Prototyping Journal， 2017， 23（3）：543-550.
［22］PAOLINI A， KOLLMANNSBERGER S， RANK E. Additive Manufacturing in Construction：a Review on Processes Applications， and Digital Planning Methods［J］. Additive Manufacturing， 2019， 30：100894.
［23］SEABRA M， AZEVEDO J， ARAUJO A， et al. Selective Laser Melting（SLM）and Topology Optimization for Lighter Aerospace Components［J］. Procedia Structural Integrity， 2016， 1：289-296.
［24］CULMONE C， SMIT G， BREEDVELD P. Additive Manufacturing of Medical Instruments：a State-of-the-art Review［J］. Additive Manufacturing， 2019， 27：461-473.
［25］DILBEROGLU U M， GHAREHPAPAGH B， YAMAN U， et al. The Role of Additive Manufacturing in the Era of Industry 4.0［J］. Procedia Manufacturing， 2017， 11：545-554.
［26］GEBISA A W， LEMU H G. Design for Manufacturing to Design for Additive Manufacturing：Analysis of Implications for Design Optimality and Product Sustainability［J］. Procedia Manufacturing， 2017， 13：724-731.
［27］XIA L， BREITKOPF P. Concurrent Topology Optimization Design of Material and Structure within FE2 Nonlinear Multiscale Analysis Framework［J］. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering， 2014， 278：524-542.
［28］XIA L， BREITKOPF P. Multiscale Structural Topology Optimization with an Approximate Constitutive Model for Local Material Microstructure［J］. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering， 2015， 286：147-167.
［29］XIA L， BREITKOPF P. Recent Advances on Topology Optimization of Multiscale Nonlinear Structures［J］. Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering， 2017， 24（2）：227-249.
［30］ZHOU L， ZHANG W H. Topology Optimization Method with Elimination of Enclosed Voids［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2019， 60（1）：117-136.
［31］MORGAN H D， CHERRY J A， JONNALA-GADDA S， et al. Part Orientation Optimization for the Additive Layer Manufacture of Metal Components［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology， 2016， 86（5）：1679-1687.
［32］JIU L， ZHANG W， MENG L， et al. A CAD-oriented Structural Topology Optimization Method［J］. Computers & Structures， 2020， 239：106324.
［33］SONG L， GAO T， TANG L， et al. An All-movable Rudder Designed by Thermo-elastic Topology Optimization and Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing［J］. Computers & Structures， 2021， 243：106405.
［34］MENG L， ZHANG W， QUAN D， et al. From Topology Optimization Design to Additive Manufacturing：Todays Success and Tomorrows Roadmap［J］. Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering， 2020， 27（3）：805-830.
［35］TOMLIN M， MEYER J. Topology Optimization of an Additive Layer Manufactured（ALM）Aerospace Part［C］∥ The 7th Altair CAE Technology Conference2011. Gaydon， Warwickshire， 2011：1-9.
［36］WU Y， QIU W， XIA L， et al. Design of an Aircraft Engine Bracket Using Stress-constrained Bi-directional Evolutionary Structural Optimization Method［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2021， 64（6）：4147-4159.
［37］SHI G H， GUAN C Q， QUAN D L， et al. An Aerospace Bracket Designed by Thermo-elastic Topology Optimization and Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing［J］. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics， 2020， 33（4）：1252-1259.
［38］BENDSE M P. Optimal Shape Design as a Material Distribution Problem［J］. Structural Optimization， 1989， 1：193-202.
［39］BENDSE M P， SIGMUND O. Material Interpolation Schemes in Topology Optimization［J］. Archive of Applied Mechanics， 1999， 69：635-654.
［40］ROZVANY G. Aims， Scope， Methods， History and Unified Terminology of Computer-aided Topology Optimization in Structural Mechanics［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2001， 21（2）：90-108.
［41］STOLPE M， SVANBERG K. On the Trajectories of Penalization Methods for Topology Optimization［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2001， 21（2）：128-139.

[1]	WEN Guilin, CHEN Gaoxi, WANG Hongxin, XUE Liang, WEI Peng, LIU Jie, . Time Domain Dynamics Topology Optimization of Functionally Gradient Material Structures with Self-weight Load [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2774-2782.
[2]	HE HonglinZ, HAO Weipeng, YU Zhihao, LONG Yufan, YAN Yinqi, LI Ji. Topological Dynamics Optimization of Constrained Damping Plates Based on Bilinear Material Interpolation Model [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2783-2789，2878.
[3]	JIANG Chuangyu, ZHANG Baoqiang, CHEN Yun, WANG Cunfu, LUO Huageng, HU Jiexiang, CAO Longchao. Study on Mechanics Properties and Numerical Convergence of Gyroid Cellular Structures [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2790-28000.
[4]	DING Yandong, LUO Nianmeng, YANG Aodi, WANG Shuting, ZHU Haoran, XIE Xianda. Efficient Multigrid Isogeometric Topology Optimization under Bézier Element Stiffness Mapping [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2801-2810.
[5]	YANG Yuhao, ZHENG Wei, WANG Yingjun, . An Efficient Isogeometric Topology Optimization Method Using DOF Reduction and Convergence Acceleration [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2811-2821.
[6]	ZOU Wuyou, DU Chun, AI Jianping, SHAN Bin. Optimization Design of TiO2 Porous Ceramic Structures for Catalyst Carrier Applications [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2833-2843.
[7]	JIAO Chen, CHAO Long, ZHU Lei, SHEN Lida, LIANG Huixin, DAI Ning, WANG Changjiang, SUN Jun. Design and Manufacture Method of Bionic Porous Structures for Orthopedic Implants [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2844-2850.
[8]	TANG Yongfeng, LU Ping, LIU Bin, JIANG Kaiyong, YAN Binggong, LIU Jiawei, HAN Wei, . Design and Mechanics Property Analysis for Different Graded Irregular Porous Structures [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2859-2866.
[9]	CUI Yupeng, YU Yang, YU Jianxing, LI Zhenmian, . Topology-size-material Joint Optimization Design of Long-pan Unsupported Decks [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2879-2887，2897.
[10]	JIA Lianhui, LI Xiaoke, YUAN Wenzheng, HE Wenbin, LIAO Zhaojin. Lightweight Design of Front and Middle Shield Structures Based on Topology Optimization and Kriging Model [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(23): 2888-2897.
[11]	WU Hanlin, WEI Peitang, CAI Lei, HU Rui, LIU Huaiju, DU Xuesong, ZHU Caichao, LIU Lang. Optimization of Planetary Roller Screw Tolerance Matching Based on Machining Error Sensitivity Analysis and Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Processes [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(22): 2693-2703.
[12]	ZHANG Junfeng, SHI Yaoyao, LIN Xiaojun, WU Xiaojun. Modeling of Material Removal Depth in ABFW Polishing Based on Modified Preston Equation [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(22): 2711-2716.
[13]	KE Qingdi, SUN Boao, XUE Bing, ZHANG Lei, CHEN Pengfei. Green Design Knowledge Expression and Acquisition Method under Product Performance Association [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(22): 2717-2726.
[14]	TUO Junbo, PENG Qiuyuan, ZHANG Xianmin, LI Congbo. Energy Consumption Prediction Method for Industrial Robots [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(22): 2727-2732,2740.
[15]	LI Shougang, LIU Peng, LIU Xiang, HU Zhili, . Rebound Law and Precision Compensation Method of Three-dimensional Laser Cutting of High Strength Steel Hot Stamping Structural Parts [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(22): 2741-2747.