[云制造]云制造再探讨

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 云制造概念于2010年被提出后，相关研究已进行了8年多，取得了巨大的进展。然而，现有研究表明，人们对云制造中的若干关键问题还存在不一致的理解，对云制造的开展和实施缺乏明确、具体的思路，关于云制造定义也有不同表述。为此，对以上问题进行再探讨，并给出了一个可能的云制造定义，最后提出了云制造未来有待进一步研究的若干关键问题。

关键词: 云制造, 云计算, 信息物理系统, 面向服务的制造

Abstract: Since the concept of cloud manufacturing was proposed in 2010，relevant researches were ongoing for more than eight years，and much progresses were made.However，existing studies indicated that there lacked common understandings of a number of critical issues in cloud manufacturing among researchers.There still lacked clear and concrete ideas for implementation of cloud manufacturing.There were also a number of different definitions for cloud manufacturing.Motivated by this，the aforementioned issues were re-discussed and an alternative definition of cloud manufacturing was presented.Finally，some key issues of cloud manufacturing to be addressed in the future were put forward.

Key words: cloud manufacturing, cloud computing, cyber-physical system（CPS）, service-oriented manufacturing

中图分类号:

TH186
TP11

刘永奎, 王力翚, 王曦, 徐旬. [云制造]云制造再探讨[J]. 中国机械工程.

LIU Yongkui, WANG Lihui, WANG Xi Vincent, XU Xun. A Revisit to Cloud Manufacturing[J]. China Mechanical Engineering.

参考文献

[1]李伯虎，张霖，王时龙，等.云制造：面向服务的网络化制造新模式[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2010，16（1）：1-8.
LI Bohu，ZHANG Lin，WANG Shilong，et al.Cloud Manufacturing：a New Service-oriented Networked Manufacturing Model[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2010，16（1）：1-8.
[2]李伯虎，柴旭东，张霖.智慧云制造：一种互联网与制造业深度融合的新模式、新手段和新业态[J］.中兴通讯技术，2016，22（5）：2-6.
LI Bohu，CHAI Xudong，ZHANG Lin.Smart Cloud Manufacturing：a New Kind of Manufacturing Paradigm，Approach and Ecosystem of Deep Integration of the Internet
and the Manufacturing Industry[J］.ZTE Technology Journal，2016，22（5）：2-6.
[3]LIU Yongkui，WANG Lihui，WANG X V.Cloud Manufacturing：Latest Advancements and Future Trends[J］.Procedia Manufacturing，2018，25：62-73.
[4]航天云网-INDICS平台[EB/OL］.[2018-04-16］.http：//www.casicloud.com/.CASICloud-INDUCS platform[EB/OL］.[2018-04-16］.http：//www.casicloud.com/.
[5]ADAMSON G，WANG Lihui，HOLM M，et al.Cloud Manufacturing：a Critical Review of Recent Development and Future Trends[J］.International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing，2017，30（4/5）：347-380.
[6]XU Xun.From Cloud Computing to Cloud Manufacturing[J］.Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing，2012，28（1）：75-86.
[7]ZHANG Qi，CHENG Lu，BOUTABA R.Cloud Computing：State-of-the-art and Research Challenges[J］.Journal of Internet Services and Applications，2010，1：7-18.
[8]ZHANG Lin，LUO Yongliang，TAO F，et al.Cloud Manufacturing：a New Manufacturing Paradigm[J］.Enterprise Information Systems，2014，8（2）：167-187.
[9]LU Yuqian，XU Xun，XU Jenny.Development of a Hybrid Manufacturing Cloud[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Systems，2014，33（4）：551-566.
[10]台德艺，徐福缘，胡伟.云制造合作思想与实现[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2012，18（7）：1575-1583.
TAI Deyi，XU Fuyuan，HU Wei.Cooperation Concept and Implementation of Cloud Manufacturing[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2012，18（7）：1575-1583.
[11]MindSphere[EB/OL］.[2018-04-16］.https：//www.siemens.com/cn/zh/home/products/software/mindsphere.html.
[12]MELL P M，GRANCE T.NIST SP-800-145 The NIST Definition of Cloud Computing[S］.Nashington DC：NIST,2011.
[13]黄沈权，顾新建，陈芨熙，等.制造云服务的按需供应模式及其关键技术[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2013，19（9）：2315-2324.
HUANG Shenquan，GU Xinjian，CHEN Jixi，et al.On-demand Supply Mode of Manufacturing Cloud Service and Its Key Technologies[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing
Systems，2013，19（9）：2315-2324.
[14]LU Yuqian，XU Xun.Protecting Intellectual Property in a Cloud Manufacturing Environment：Requirements and Strategies[C］//IFIP International Conference on Advances in
Production Management Systems.Cham：Springer，2015：404-411.
[15]李伯虎，张霖，任磊，等.再论云制造[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2011，17（3）：449-457.
LI Bohu，ZHANG Lin，REN Lei，et al.Further Discussion on Cloud Manufacturing[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2011，17（3）：449-457.
[16]WANG Lihui，WANG X V.Cloud-based Cyber-physical Systems in Manufacturing[M］.Berlin：Springer，2018.
[17]RIMAL B P，JUKAN A，KATSAROS D，et al.Architectural Requirements for Cloud Computing Sysems：an Enterprise Cloud Approach[J］.Journal of Grid Computing，2011，9（1）：3-26.
[18]MORGAN J，O'DONNELL G E.Enabling a Ubiquitous and Cloud Manufacturing Foundation with Field-level Service-oriented Architecture[J］.International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing，2017，30（4/5）：442-458.
[19]WANG X V，XUN W.An Interoperable Solution for Cloud Manufacturing[J］.Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing，2013，29（4）：232-247.
[20]WANG X V，WANG Lihui，G-RDES R.Interoperability in Cloud Manufacturing：a Case Study on Private Cloud Structure for SMEs[J］.International Journal of Computer Integrated
Manufacturing，2018，31（7）：653-663.
[21]LIU Xiaoqing，SHAHRIAR M R，SUNNY S N A，et al.Cyber-Physical Manufacturing Cloud：Architecture，Virtualization，Communication，and Testbed[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Systems，2017，43：352-364.
[22]MORARIU O，MORARIU C，BORANGIU T.Shop-floor Resource Virtualization Layer with Private Cloud Support[J］.Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing，2016，27（2）：447-462.
[23]LIU Yongkui，WANG Lihui，WANG X V，et al.Scheduling in Cloud Manufacturing：State-of-the-art and Research Challenges[J］.International Journal of Production Research，2018：1449978.
[24]BUCKHOLT Z B，RAGAI I，WANG Lihui.Remote Equipment Security in Cloud Manufacturing Systems[J］.International Journal of Manufacturing Research，2016，11（2）：126-143.
[25]Tao F，Zhang L，VENKATESH V C，et al.Cloud Manufacturing：a Computing and Service-oriented Manufacturing Model[J］.Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers，Part B:Journal of Engineering Manufacture，2011，225（10）：1969-1976.
[26]张霖，罗永亮，范文慧，等.云制造及相关先进制造模式分析[J］.计算机集成制造系，2011，17（3）：458-468.
ZHANG Lin，LUO Yongliang，FAN Wenhui，et al.Analyses of Cloud Manufacturing and Related Advanced Manufacturing Models[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2011，17（3）：458-468.
[27]WANG Peng，GAO R X，FAN Zhaoyan.Cloud Computing for Cloud Manufacturing：Benefits and Limitations[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering，2015，137（4）：040901.
[28]COULLON H，NOYé J.Reconsidering the Relationship between Cloud Computing and Cloud Manufacturing[M］//Service Orientation in Holonic and Multi-agent Manufacturing.Cham：Springer，2018：217-228.
[29]TAO Fei，ZUO Ying，XU Lida，et al.IoT-based Intelligent Perception and Access of Manufacturing Resource Toward Cloud Manufacturing[J］.IEEE Transactions on Industrial
Informatics，2014，10（2）：1547-1557.
[30]WANG Lihui，WANG X V，GAO Liang，et al.A Cloud-based Approach for WEEE Remanufacturing[J］.CIRP Annals:Manufacturing Technology，2014，63（1）：409-412.
[31]WANG Lihui，MARTIN T，MAURO O.Current Status and Advancement of Cyber-Physical Systems in Manufacturing[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Systems，2015，37：517-527.
[32]张霖，罗永亮，陶飞，等.制造云构建关键技术研究[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2010，16（11）：2510-2520.
ZHANG Lin，LUO Yongliang，TAO Fei，et al.Key Technologies for The Construction of Manufacturing Cloud[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2010，16（11）：2510-2520.
[33]WANG Lihui.Machine Availability Monitoring and Machining Process Planning towards Cloud Manufacturing[J］.CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology，2013，6（4）：263-273.
[34]孙林岩，李刚，江志斌，等.21 世纪的先进制造模式：服务型制造[J］.中国机械工程，2007，18（19）：2307-2312.
SUN Linyan，LI Gang，JIANG Zhibin，et al.Service-embedded Manufacturing：Advanced Manufacturing Paradigm in 21st Century[J］.，2007，18（19）：2307-2312.
[35]王时龙，郭亮，康玲，等.云制造应用模式探讨及方案分析[J］.计算机集成制造系统，2012，18（7）：1637-1643.
WANG Shilong，GUO Liang，KANG Ling，et al.Cloud Manufacturing Application Mode and Program Analysis[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2012，18（7）：1637-1643.
[36]陶飞，张霖，郭华，等.云制造特征及云服务组合关键问题研究[J］.2011，17（3）：477-486.
TAO Fei，ZHANG Lin，GUO Hua，et al.Typical Characteristics of Cloud Manufacturing and Several Key Issues of Cloud Service Composition[J］.Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2011，17（3）：477-486.
[37]WU Dazhong，THAMES J L，ROSEN D W，et al.Towards a Cloud-based Design and Manufacturing Paradigm：Looking Backward，Looking Forward[C］//ASME 2012 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference.Chicago，2012：315-328.
[38]FISHER O，WATSON N，PORCU L，et al.Cloud Manufacturing as a Sustainable Process Manufacturing route[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Systems，2018，47：53-68.
[39]LIU Yongkui，XU Xun.Industry 4.0 and Cloud Manufacturing：a Comparative Analysis[J］.Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering，2017，139（3）：034701.
[40]工业互联网平台白皮书（2017）[EB/OL］.[2018-04-16］.http：//www.miit.gov.cn/n973401/n5993937/ n5993968/c6002326/content.html.
White Paper on Industrial Internet Platform （2017） [EB/OL］.[2018-04-16］.http：//www.miit.gov.cn/n973401/n5993937/n5993968/c6002326/content.html.
[41]KANG H S，LEE J Y，CHOI S S，et al.Smart Manufacturing：Past Research，Present Findings，and Future Directions[J］.International Journal of Precision Engineering and
Manufacturing-Green Technology，2016，3（1）：111-128.
[42]JIANG Pingyu，DING Kai，LENG Jiewu.Towards a Cyber-Physical-Social-connected and Service-oriented Manufacturing Paradigm：Social Manufacturing[J］.Manufacturing Letters，2016，7：15-21.
[43]TAO Fei，CHENG Jiangfeng，QI Qinglin，et al.Digital Twin-driven Product Design，Manufacturing and Service with Big Data[J］.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology，2018，94（9/12）：3563-3576.
[44]LIU Yongkui，XU Xun，SRINIVASAN A，et al.Enterprises in Cloud Manufacturing：a Preliminary Exploration[C］//ASME 12th International Manufacturing Science and Engineering
Conference collocated with the JSME/ASME 6th International Conference on Materials and Processing.Los Angeles，2017：V003T04A042.
[45]Radziwon A，Bilberg A，Bogers M，et al.The Smart Factory：Exploring Adaptive and Flexible Manufacturing Solutions[J］.Procedia Engineering，2014，69：1184-1190.