轴向低频振动对皮质骨钻削进给力的影响试验与分析

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-132X.2023.20.003

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 为了研究轴向低频振动辅助钻削方式在皮质骨钻削过程中对进给力的影响，对全钻头和横刃部分进给力进行了对比试验，并对切削刃切削单元的运动学和瞬时加工过程进行了分析。对比试验结果表明：在相同的钻削参数下，与常规方式相比，轴向低频振动钻削方式的全钻头进给力最大可减小约60%，横刃部分进给力可减小60%~80%。依据运动学分析和典型骨屑形态对比可以得出：在特定的钻削参数和振动参数配合下，轴向低频振动钻削方式可以实现钻头工件周期性分离运动，显著影响瞬态加工过程，是进给力显著减小的主要原因之一。

关键词: 骨钻削, 低频振动辅助钻削, 运动学分析, 瞬态加工, 进给力

Abstract: For studying the effects of axial LFVAD method on the feed forces in the cortical bone drilling processes, the comparative experiments of feed forces for whole drill bit and chisel edge were performed. The kinematics analyses and the transient machining processes of the cutting unit in LFVAD method were also studied. The experimental results show that, compared with conventional drilling(CD) method, the feed forces of whole drill bit and chisel edge in LFVAD method decrease about 60% and 60%~80% respectively with the same drilling parameters. According to the analyses of kinematics and the comparisons of typical morphology of bone chips, a periodic separation motion between the drill bit and workpiece may be achieved in LFVAD method with the specific drilling and vibration parameters. This motion may significantly change the transient machining processes. This motion may be one of the main reasons for the feed force reduction.

Key words: bone drilling, low-frequency vibration-assisted drilling（LFVAD）, kinematics analysis, transient machining, feed force

中图分类号:

TH162.1

白小帆, 刘志强, 刘彦士. 轴向低频振动对皮质骨钻削进给力的影响试验与分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2023, 34(20): 2411-2427.

BAI Xiaofan, LIU Zhiqiang, LIU Yanshi. Experiments and Analyses of Effects of Axial Low-frequency Vibration on Feed Forces of Cortical Bone Drilling[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(20): 2411-2427.

参考文献

［1］白小帆, 侯书军, 李慨,等. 轴向低频振动辅助皮质骨钻削的钻削力和温升［J］. 中国机械工程, 2021, 32(3):321-330.
BAI Xiaofan, HOU Shujun, LI Kai, et al. Drilling Forces and Temperature Rises in Axial Low-frequency Vibration-assisted Cortical Bone Drilling［J］. China Mechanical Engineering, 2021, 32(3):321-330.
［2］BACHUS K N, RONDINA M T, HUTCHINSON D T. The Effects of Drilling Force on Cortical Temperatures and Their Duration:an in Vitro Study［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2000, 22(10):685-691.
［3］ERIKSSON R A, ALBREKTSSON T, MAGNUSSON B. Assessment of Bone Viability after Heat Trauma:a Histological, Histochemical and Vital Microscopic Study in the Rabbit［J］. Scandinavian Journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 1984, 18（3）：261-268.
［4］PANDEY R K, PANDA S S. Drilling of Bone:a Comprehensive Review［J］. Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics and Trauma, 2013, 4(1):15-30.
［5］SEZEK S, AKSAKAL B, KARACA F. Influence of Drill Parameters on Bone Temperature and Necrosis: a FEM Modelling and in Vitro Experiments［J］. Computational Materials Science, 2012, 60:13-18.
［6］SINGH G, JINDAL R, JAIN V, et al. Effect of Tool and Drilling Parameters on Surface Topography of Bone Drilled Holes:an in vitro Study［J］. 2016 International Conference for Students on Applied Engineering. Tyne, 2016:196-200.
［7］ALAM K, HASSAN E, IMRAN S H, et al. In-vitro Analysis of Forces in Conventional and Ultrasonically Assisted Drilling of Bone［J］. Bio-medical Materials and Engineering, 2016, 27(1):101-110.
［8］LUGHMANI W A, BOUAZZA-MAROUF K, ASHCROFT I. Drilling in Cortical Bone: a Finite Element Model and Experimental Investigations［J］. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 2015, 42(42C):32-42.
［9］SENER B C, DERGIN G, GURSOY B, et al. Effects of Irrigation Temperature on Heat Control in vitro at Different Drilling Depths［J］. Clinical Oral Implants Research, 2009, 20(3):294-298.
［10］BAGCI E, OZCELIK B. Effects of Different Cooling Conditions on Twist Drill Temperature［J］. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2007, 34(9/10):867-877.
［11］AUGUSTIN G, DAVILA S, UDILLJAK T, et al. Temperature Changes during Cortical Bone Drilling with a Newly Designed Step Drill and an Internally Cooled Drill［J］. International Orthopaedics, 2012, 36(7):1449-1456.
［12］ALAM K, HASSAN E, BAHADUR I. Experimental Measurements of Temperatures in Ultrasonically Assisted Drilling of Cortical Bone［J］. Biotechnology and Biotechnological Equipment, 2015, 29(4):753-757.
［13］SINGH R P, PANDEY P M, MRIDHA A R. An In-vitro Study of Temperature Rise during Rotary Ultrasonic Bone Drilling of Human Bone［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2020, 79:33-43.
［14］SUGITA N, ISHII K, SUI J, et al. Multi-grooved Cutting Tool to Reduce Cutting Force and Temperature during Bone Machining［J］. CIRP Annals, 2014, 63(1):101-104.
［15］LI Z, YANG D, HAO W, et al. A Novel Technique for Micro-hole Forming on Skull with the Assistance of Ultrasonic Vibration［J］. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 2016, 57:1-13.
［16］ALAM K, GHAFOOR A, SILBERSCHMIDT V V. Analysis of Forces and Temperatures in Conventional and Ultrasonically-assisted Cutting of Bone［C］∥Advanced Materials Research. Sintra, 2011(223):247-254.
［17］ALAM K, MITROFANOV A V, SILBERSCHMIDT V V. Experimental Investigations of Forces and Torque in Conventional and Ultrasonically-assisted Drilling of Cortical Bone［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2011, 33(2):234-239.
［18］ALAM K, SILBERSCHMIDT V V. Analysis of Temperature in Conventional and Ultrasonically-assisted Drilling of Cortical Bone with Infrared Thermography［J］. Technology and Health Care, 2014, 22(2):243-252.
［19］ALAM K, AL-GHAITHI A, PIYA S, et al. In-vitro Experimental Study of Histopathology of Bone in Vibrational Drilling［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2019, 67:78-87.
［20］BAI X, HOU S, LI K, et al. Experimental Investigation of the Temperature Elevation in Bone Drilling Using Conventional and Vibration-assisted Methods［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2019, 69:1-7.
［21］WANG Y, CAO M, ZHAO X, et al. Experimental Investigations and Finite Element Simulation of Cutting Heat in Vibrational and Conventional Drilling of Cortical Bone［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2014, 36(11):1408-1415.
［22］赵琪, 李慨, 侯书军,等. 扭转振动骨钻削切削参数与钻削力的试验研究［J］. 机械设计与制造, 2019, 11:98-101.
ZHAO Qi, LI Kai, HOU Shujun, et al. Experimental Study on Cutting Parameters and Drilling Force by Torsional Vibration Bone Drilling［J］. Machinery Design and Manufacture, 2019,11:98-101.
［23］LEE J, GOZEN B A, OZDOGANLAR O B. Modeling and Experimentation of Bone Drilling Forces［J］. Journal of Biomechanics, 2012, 45(6):1076-1083.
［24］BONO M J, NI J. The Indentation Zone of a Twist Drill［C］∥North American Manufacturing Research ConferenceⅩⅩⅨ. Gainesville, 2001:MR01-274.
［25］REILLY G. Wedge Indentation Fracture of Cortical Bone: Experimental Data and Predictions［J］. Journal of Biomechanical Engineering, 2010, 132(8):081009.
［26］SUI J, SUGITA N, ISHII K,et al. Mechanistic Modeling of Bone-drilling Process with Experimental Validation［J］. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2014, 214(4):1018-1026.
［27］PANDEY R K, PANDA S S. Optimization of Bone Drilling Parameters Using Grey-based Fuzzy Algorithm［J］. Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation, 2014, 47(1):386-392.
［28］GUPTA V, PANDEY P M. Experimental Investigation and Statistical Modeling of Temperature Rise in Rotary Ultrasonic Bone Drilling［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2016, 38(11):1330-1338.
［29］TAHMASBI V, GHOREISHI M, ZOLFAGHARI M. Investigation, Sensitivity Analysis, and Multi-objective Optimization of Effective Parameters on Temperature and Force in Robotic Drilling Cortical Bone［J］. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H:Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 2017, 231(11):1012-1024.
［30］AKHBAR M F A, YUSOFF A R. Multi-objective Optimization of Surgical Drill Bit to Minimize Thermal Damage in Bone-drilling［J］. Applied Thermal Engineering, 2019, 157:113594.
［31］ALI AKHBAR M F, YUSOFF A R. Drilling of Bone: Effect of Drill Bit Geometries on Thermal Osteonecrosis Risk Regions［J］. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 2019, 233(2):207-218.
［32］GUPTA V, PANDEY P M, SILBERSCHMIDT V V. Rotary Ultrasonic Bone Drilling: Improved Pullout Strength and Reduced Damage［J］. Medical Engineering and Physics, 2017, 41:1-8.
［33］ALAM K, AHMED N, SILBERSCHMIDT V V. Comparative Study of Conventional and Ultrasonically-assisted Bone Drilling［J］. Technology and Health Care, 2014, 22(2):253-262.
［34］PANDEY R K, PANDA S S. Multi-performance Optimization of Bone Drilling Using Taguchi Method Based on Membership Function［J］. Mea-surement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation, 2015, 59:9-13.
［35］隈部淳一郎. 精密加工振动切削（基础与应用）［M］. 北京：机械工业出版社, 1985.
KUMABE J. Vibration Cutting for Precision Machining:Fundamentals and Applications［M］. Beijing:China Machine Press, 1985.
［36］WANG X, WANG L J, TAO J P. Investigation on Thrust in Vibration Drilling of Fiber-reinforced Plastics［J］. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2004, 148(2):239-244.

[1]	何宇凡, 孙江宏, 高锋, 李乃峥, 何雪萍, 王军见. 一种针对圆锥体外表面贴装的机械手设计分析与优化[J]. 中国机械工程, 2023, 34(01): 55-64.
[2]	尚祖恩, 赵丽娟, 刘雄豪, 金鑫. 煤矿救援机器人可折展水弹轮式结构分析与优化[J]. 中国机械工程, 2021, 32(24): 2924-2933.
[3]	白小帆;侯书军;李慨;曲云霞. 轴向低频振动辅助皮质骨钻削的钻削力和温升[J]. 中国机械工程, 2021, 32(03): 321-330.
[4]	龚峻山;方跃法;靳晓东. 基于并联手指结构的多功能灵巧手的设计与研究[J]. 中国机械工程, 2020, 31(23): 2837-2846.
[5]	张彦斌1,2,3;荆献领1;韩建海1,2;陈子豪1. 新型RR-RURU踝关节康复机器人机构的设计与分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2019, 30(14): 1734-1741.
[6]	彭浩;何柏岩. 星载环形天线重力补偿新方法[J]. 中国机械工程, 2019, 30(04): 379-384.
[7]	沈惠平;赵迎春;许可;张震;杨廷力. 一种可重构、部分运动解耦的空间n维平移1维转动并联机构的拓扑及其运动学设计[J]. 中国机械工程, 2019, 30(04): 413-422.
[8]	荣誉1,2,3;刘双勇3;王洪斌1;韩勇3. 一种3-DOF并联机械手的研制[J]. 中国机械工程, 2018, 29(03): 253-261.
[9]	周少瑞;刘宏昭. 一种3-CRCR/RPU对称并联机器人机构工作空间及运动学分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2017, 28(20): 2500-2508.
[10]	朱伟;戴志明;刘晓飞;沈惠平;朱小蓉;何宝祥. 一种新型弱耦合三平移并联机器人机构及其运动学分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2017, 28(13): 1561-1566,1607.
[11]	张彦斌, 丁丁, 吴鑫, 王增辉, 赵浥夫. 2PRS-2PSS并联机构的设计与运动学分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2016, 27(21): 2855-2861.
[12]	高艺, 马国庆, 于正林, 曹国华. 一种六自由度工业机器人运动学分析及三维可视化仿真[J]. 中国机械工程, 2016, 27(13): 1726-1731.
[13]	李阁强, 王帅, 邓效忠, 周斌. 新型全液压重载锻造机器人机构设计及分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2016, 27(09): 1168-1175.
[14]	沈惠平, 杨梁杰, 邓嘉鸣, 张晓玉, 沈晓军. 用于肩关节康复训练的单输入三转动输出并联机构及其运动学设计[J]. 中国机械工程, 2015, 26(22): 2983-2988.
[15]	王吉岱1, 连金玲1, 2. 气动式除冰机器人及其运动学分析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2013, 24(5): 610-613,627.