Influences of Horizontal Forced Vibration Finishing on Surface Integrity Parameters of TC4 Titanium Alloys

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-132X.2023.17.003

Abstract

Abstract: To explore the influences of horizontal forced vibration finishing on the surface integrity of TC4 titanium alloy specimens， a single factor experiment was designed to analyze the effects of main processing parameters on surface roughness， microhardness， surface residual stress and contact angle， a better combination of processing parameters was obtained. The changes of the surface morphology， microstructure and surface lattice of the specimens were analyzed before and after processing under the optimal parameters. The results show that particle diameter is the main factor affecting surface roughness， microhardness and surface residual stress. As the particle diameter becomes larger， the roughness reduction rate increases first and then decreases， and the microhardness and surface residual compressive stress become larger. With the increasing of amplitude and frequency， the decreasing rate of surface roughness， microhardness and surface residual compressive stress increase. The maximum decreasing rate of surface roughness Ra， Rq， Rz， Rt and RSm may reach 65.0%， 62.2%， 45.2%， 42.0% and 73.7% respectively. Microhardness may be increased from 320.8HV0.1 to 363.9HV0.1. The residual compressive stress may be changed from -420.38 MPa to -621.25 MPa. The surface peaks are removed. A dense layer is formed on the surface， and the grain structure is refined. The diffraction peak is shifted and the greater residual compressive stresses are introduced.

Key words: horizontal forced vibration, vibration finishing, titanium alloy, surface roughness, microhardness, residual stress

摘要： 为探究水平强制振动光整加工对TC4钛合金试件表面完整性的影响，设计单因素实验分析主要工艺参数对表面粗糙度、显微硬度、表面残余应力、接触角的影响，得到较优工艺参数组合；分析较优参数下试件加工前后表面形貌、显微组织及表面晶格变化。研究结果表明：颗粒直径是影响表面粗糙度、显微硬度及残余应力的主要因素。随着颗粒直径的增大，表面粗糙度下降率先提高后降低，显微硬度和残余压应力增大；随着振幅、频率的增大，表面粗糙度下降率提高，显微硬度和残余压应力增大。加工后试件表面粗糙度Ra、Rq、Rz、Rt、RSm最大下降率分别为65.0%、62.2%、45.2%、42.0%和73.7%；显微硬度从320.8HV0.1增大至363.9HV0.1；表面残余压应力从-420.38 MPa变化为-621.25 MPa；表面波峰被去除，表层形成了致密层，晶粒组织得到了细化；衍射峰发生了偏移，并引入了数值更大的残余压应力。

关键词: 水平强制振动, 振动式光整加工, 钛合金, 表面粗糙度, 显微硬度, 残余应力

CLC Number:

TG176
TH161

HAN Rui, LI Xiuhong, WANG Jiaming, LI Wenhui, CHENG Siyuan, YANG Shengqiang, . Influences of Horizontal Forced Vibration Finishing on Surface Integrity Parameters of TC4 Titanium Alloys[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(17): 2037-2047.

韩锐, 李秀红, 王嘉明, 李文辉, 程思源, 杨胜强, . 水平强制振动光整加工对TC4钛合金表面完整性参数的影响[J]. 中国机械工程, 2023, 34(17): 2037-2047.

References

［1］季文彬，邓日清，戴士杰，等. 铣削对SLM增材TC4钛合金表面完整性和疲劳性能的影响［J］. 中国机械工程， 2023， 34（2）：208-217.
JI Wenbin， DENG Riqing， DAI Shijie， et al. Effects of Milling on Surface Integrity and Fatigue Performance of TC4 Titanium Alloy by SLM［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2023， 34（2）：208-217.
［2］李秀红，王嘉明，李文辉，等. 航空发动机铣削叶片抛磨技术研究现状及其发展趋势［J/OL］. 机械科学与技术：1-11. ［2023-01-02］. https：∥kns. cnki. net/kcms/detail/detail. aspx?FileName=JXKX202206 1500U&DbName=CAPJ2022.
LI Xiuhong， WANG Jiaming， LI Wenhui， et al. Research Status and Development Trend of Aero-engine Milling Blade Polishing Technology［J/OL］. Mechanical Science and Technology for Aerospace Engineering：1-11. ［2023-01-02］. https：∥kns. cnki. net/kcms/detail/detail. aspx?FileName=JXKX20 22061500U&DbName=CAPJ2022
［3］李凤琴，赵波，郝旺身，等. 超声纵扭铣削钛合金表面形貌特性及有效性分析［J］. 中国机械工程， 2023， 34（6）：677-684.
LI Fengqing， ZHAO Bo， HAO Wangshen， et al. Surface Morphology Characteristics and Effectiveness Analysis of Ultrasonic Longitudinal Torsion Assisted Milling of Titanium Alloys［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2023， 34（6）：677-684.
［4］淮文博，蔺小军，史耀耀. 砂布轮柔性抛光表面完整性关键表征参数研究［J］. 机械科学与技术， 2021， 40（11）：1735-1740.
HUAI Wenbo， LIN Xiaojun， SHI Yaoyao. Study on Key Characterization Parameters of Surface Integrity in Flexible Polishing of Abrasive Cloth Wheel［J］. Mechanical Science and Technology for Aerospace Engineering， 2021， 40（11）：1735-1740.
［5］黄新春，张定华，姚倡锋，等. 镍基高温合金GH4169磨削参数对表面完整性影响［J］. 航空动力学报， 2013， 28（3）：621-628.
HUANG Xinchun， ZHANG Dinghua， YAO Changfeng， et al. Effects of Grinding Parameters on Surface Integrity of GH4169 Nickel-based Super-alloy［J］. Journal of Aerospace Power， 2013， 28（3）：621-628.
［6］段练，黄云，邹莱. 机器人砂带磨削GH4169镍基高温合金表面完整性研究［J］. 中国机械工程， 2019， 30（17）：2044-2050.
DUAN Lian， HUANG Yun， ZOU Lai. Research on Surface Integrity of GH4169 Nickel-based Super-alloys by Robotic Belt Grinding［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2019， 30（17）：2044-2050.
［7］丁文锋，李敏，李本凯，等. 难加工金属材料磨削加工表面完整性研究进展［J］. 航空材料学报， 2021， 41（4）：36-56.
DING Wenfeng， LI Min， LI Benkai， et al. Recent Progress on Surface Integrity of Grinding Difficult-to-cut Metal Materials［J］. Journal of Aeronautical Materials， 2021， 41（4）：36-56.
［8］卜嘉利，吕扬，刘博志，等. 不同喷丸强度对TC17钛合金抗疲劳性能影响［J］. 航空动力学报， 2022， 37（6）：1225-1233.
BU Jiali， LYU Yang， LIU Bozhi， et al. Effect of Different Shot Peening Intensities on Fatigue Resistance of TC17 Titanium Alloy［J］. Journal of Aerospace Power， 2022， 37（6）：1225-1233.
［9］王欣，胡云辉，王晓峰，等. 喷丸强化对FGH96粉末高温合金疲劳性能应力集中敏感性的影响［J］. 航空制造技术， 2017， 532（13）：48-53.
WANG Xin， HU Yunhui， WANG Xiaofeng， et al. Effect of Shot Peening on Fatigue Performance Stress-concentration Sensitivity of FGH96 Powder Metallurgy Superalloy［J］. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology， 2017， 532（13）：48-53.
［10］HUANG Qi， REN Jingxin. Surface Integrity and its Effects on the Fatigue Life of the Nickel-based Superalloy GH33A［J］. International Journal of Fatigue， 1991， 13（4）：322-326.
［11］杨胜强，王明珠，杨世春，等. 曲轴类零件滚磨光整加工技术的开发与研究［J］. 中国机械工程， 2001， 12（3）：68-70.
YANG Shengqiang， WANG Mingzhu， YANG Shichun， et al. The Development and Study on Barrel Finishing of the Family of Crank Parts［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2001， 12（3）：68-70.
［12］杨胜强，王秀枝，李文辉. 振动式滚磨光整加工技术的研究现状及再发展［J］. 太原理工大学学报， 2017， 48（3）：385-392.
YANG Shengqiang， WANG Xiuzhi， LI Wenhui. Research Status and Further Development of Vibratory Finishing Technology［J］. Journal of Taiyuan University of Technology， 2017， 48（3）：385-392.
［13］SANGID M D， STORI J A， FERRIERA P M. Process Characterization of Vibrostrengthening and Application to Fatigue Enhancement of Aluminum Aerospace Components—Part Ⅰ. Experimental Study of Process Parameters［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology， 2011， 53（5/8）：545-560.
［14］LACHENMAIER M， DEHMER A， TRAUTH D， et al. Influence of Different Input Parameters on the Contact Conditions Determing the Surface Integrity of Workpieces in an Unguided Vibratory Finishing Process［J］. Procedia CIRP， 2018， 71：53-58.
［15］EIFLER M， GARRETSON I C， LINKE B S， et al. Effects of Vibratory Finishing of 304 Stainless Steel Samples on Areal Roughness Parameters：a Correlational Analysis for Anisotropy Parameters［J］. Journal of Materials Processing Technology， 2019， 273：116256.
［16］KARTHIK R， ELANGOVAN K， SHANKAR S， et al. An Experimental Analysis on Surface Roughness of the Selective Laser Sintered and UnsinteredInconel 718 Components Using Vibratory Surface Finishing Process［J］. Materials Today：Proceedings， 2022， 64（1）：220-224.
［17］PANDIYAN V， CASTAGNE S， SUBBIAH S. High Frequency and Amplitude Effects in Vibratory Media Finishing［J］. Procedia Manufacturing， 2016， 5：546-557.
［18］吴远超，李秀红，王嘉明，等. 水平振动抛磨颗粒介质流场特性分析［J］. 表面技术， 2021， 50（11）：329-338.
WU Yuanchao， LI Xiuhong， WANG Jiaming， et al. Flow Field Characteristics Analysis of Media for Horizontal Vibratory Mass Finishing［J］. Surface Technology， 2021， 50（11）：329-338.
［19］李昊，李秀红，王嘉明，等. 叶片安装高度对水平振动抛磨介质作用行为影响［J］. 组合机床与自动化加工技术， 2022（11）：6-10.
LI Hao， LI Xiuhong， WANG Jiaming， et al. Analysis of Action Behavior of Granular Medium on Blade in One-dimensional Vibration Polishing［J］. Modular Machine Tool & Automatic Manufacturing Technique， 2022（11）：6-10.
［20］王志成，李文辉，李秀红，等. 整体叶盘回转辅助水平振动式抛磨的颗粒力学行为仿真分析［J］. 金刚石与磨料磨具工程， 2022， 42（5）：617-625.
WANG Zhicheng， LI Wenhui， LI Xiuhong， et al. Simulation Analysis of Particle Mechanical Behavior in Rotary-assisted Horizontal Vibration Polishing of Blisk［J］. Diamond & Abrasives Engineering， 2022， 42（5）：617-625.
［21］李秀红，李文辉，杨胜强，等. 一种用于叶片表面加工的组合封闭型腔振动式滚磨光整加工装置及其方法：CN110842749B［P］. 2021-05-28.
LI Xiuhong， LI Wenhui， YANG Shengqiang， et al. A Combined Closed Cavity Vibration Rolling Finishing Device and Method for Blade Surface Machining：CN110842749B［P］. 2021-05-28.
［22］CHENG K， SHAO Y Z， JADVA M， et al. Development of the Improved Preston Equation for Abrasive Flow Machining of Aerofoil Structures and Components［J］. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers， Part J：Journal of Engineering Tribology， 2019， 233（9）：1397-1404.
［23］SAEKI M. Impact Damping with Granular Materials in a Horizontally Vibrating System［J］. Journal of Sound and Vibration， 2002， 251（1）：153-161.
［24］卢俊亮，李秀红，李文辉，等. 一维振动式滚磨光整贴壁式加工工艺实验研究［J］. 机械科学与技术， 2021， 40（1）：84-91.
LU Junliang， LI Xiuhong， LI Wenhui， et al. Experimental Study on Adherent Processing Technology of One-dimensional Vibration Finishing［J］. Mechanical Science and Technology for Aerospace Engineering， 2021， 40（1）：84-91.
［25］LEACH R. Characterisation of Areal Surface Texture［M］. New York：Springer Science & Business Media， 2013：282-283.
［26］张元良，李瑞品，王金龙，等. 基于不同粗糙度Ra与Rz的FV520B-I超高周疲劳失效研究［J］. 机械设计与制造， 2021（8）：38-42.
ZHANG Yuanliang， LI Ruipin， WANG Jinlong， et al. The Study of Very-high Cycle Fatigue for FV520B-I Basedon Different Surface Roughness Ra and Rz［J］. Machinery Design & Manufacture， 2021（8）：38-42.
［27］PENA P L， MALDONADO C D， MARTINEZ C， et al. Study of the Influence of Surface Roughness Parameters on the Frictional Characteristics of Materials［J］. IOP Conference Series：Materials Science and Engineering， 2019， 591：012025.
［28］EDACHERY V， SWAMYBABU V， ADARSH D， et al. Influence of Surface Roughness Frequencies and Roughness Parameters on Lubricant Wettability Transitions in Micro-nano Scale Hierarchical Surfaces［J］. Tribology International， 2022， 165.
［29］TOMOV M， KUZINOVSKI M， CICHOSZ P， et al. Development of Mathematical Models for Surface Roughness Parameter Prediction in Turning Depending on the Process Condition［J］. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences， 2016， 113：120-132.
［30］LEE S J， RASOOLIAN B， SILVA D F， et al. Surface Roughness Parameter and Modeling for Fatigue Behavior of Additive Manufactured Parts：a Non-destructive Data-driven Approach［J］. Additive Manufacturing， 2021， 46：102094.
［31］张凯. 水平振动式滚磨光整加工颗粒介质介观尺度行为分析［D］. 太原：太原理工大学， 2022.
ZHANG Kai. Mesoscopic Scale Behavior Analysis of Granular Media in Horizontal Vibration Mass Finishing［D］. Taiyuan：Taiyuan University of Techology， 2022.
［32］王东峰，袁巨龙，王燕霜，等. 轴承沟道表面完整性研究进展［J］. 中国机械工程， 2022， 33（18）：2143-2160.
WANG Dongfeng， YUAN Julong， WANG Yanshuang， et al. Research Progresses on Surface Integrity of Bearing Grooves［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2022， 33（18）：2143-2160.
［33］丁文锋，奚欣欣，占京华，等. 航空发动机钛材料磨削技术研究现状及展望［J］. 航空学报， 2019， 40（6）：6-41.
DING Wenfeng， XI Xinxin， ZHAN Jinghua， et al. Research Status and Future Development of Grinding Technology of Titanium Materials for Aero-engines［J］. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica， 2019， 40（6）：6-41.
［34］宋嘉文. 高温高压环境下水在固体表面接触角的温度和压力依赖性研究［D］. 杭州：浙江大学， 2022.
SONG Jiawen. On the Temperature and Pressure Dependence of the Contact Angles of Water on Solid Surfaces at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures［D］. Hangzhou：Zhejiang University， 2022.
［35］YAN Y D， CHIBOWSKI E， SZCZES A. Surface Properties of Ti-6Al-4V Alloy Part Ⅰ：Surface Roughness and Apparent Surface Free Energy［J］. Materials Science and Engineering：C， 2017， 70（1）：207-215.
［36］谢乐春. TC4钛合金与钛基复合材料喷丸强化及其XRD表征［D］. 上海：上海交通大学， 2015.
XIE Lechun. Study on Shot Peening and XRD Characterization of TC4 Titanium Alloy and Titanium Matrix Composite［D］. Shanghai：Shanghai Jiao Tong University， 2015.

[1]	YANG Zihao, FAN Zenghua, ZHANG Xiang, GAO Jun. Research on Chemical-assisted Magnetorheological Shear Thickening Polishing of Titanium Alloy Tube Inner Surfaces [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(12): 2846-2853.
[2]	Wenqian LI, Zhanqiang LIU, Jinfu ZHAO, Bing WANG, Yukui CAI. Nanosecond Laser Machining of Spiral Grooves of Dry Gas Seal Rotational Ring Surfaces [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(10): 2207-2214.
[3]	Shanshan LI, Xingwei SUN, Heng YANG, Heting QIAO. Research on Nonlinear Wear Behavior of Sealing Pairs in Magnetorheological Fluid Environment [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(09): 1968-1979.
[4]	Jiyuan HAN, Jiahao ZHANG, Yong ZHAN, Hongyi ZHANG, Dongyue QU. Prediction of Residual Stress in Boring Main Bearing Holes of Marine Diesel Engine Bodies [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(08): 1883-1892.
[5]	NIU Yanzhao1, LIU Hongwei1, SONG Yali2, ZHU Xianglong1, HUANG Jiamei2, KANG Renke1. Optimization and Experimental Study of Bolt Retreat Groove Rolling Wheels Based on Finite Element Simulation [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(06): 1214-1221.
[6]	ZHENG Jintao, MA Haoran, WANG Jin, LIU Guoliang. Experimental Study of Ultrasonic Vibration Assisted Turning Titanium Alloys with Nanofluid MQL [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(04): 743-752,759.
[7]	ZHOU Jinhua1, 2, QI Qi1, 2, REN Junxue1, 2, ZHAN Mei1, 2. Inverse Solution for TC4 Residual Stress Gradient Distribution in Four-axis Milling with Tapered Ball-end Cutters [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(04): 770-779.
[8]	TAN Liang1, 2, FAN Yi3, YAO Changfeng1, 2. Investigation on Evolution Laws for Surface States of TC17 Alloy Induced by UIT during High-cycle Fatigue at 400 ℃ [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(04): 790-801.
[9]	JIAO Jiqiang1, 2, MENG Jun2, XIE Wenjun2, Guo Fangzhun1. Structure Design and Performance Study of Titanium Alloy-lined Thin-wall Chambers [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(02): 265-270.
[10]	YANG Heran1, 2, ZHANG Peijie1, 2, SUN Xingwei1, 2, PAN Fei1, 2, LIU Yin1, 2. Surface Roughness Prediction for Screw Belt Grinding Based on Improved CNN [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2025, 36(02): 325-332.
[11]	YAN Wei1, 3, WANG Xinyi2, 3, ZHANG Hua3, ZHU Shuo2, 3, JIANG Zhigang2, 3. Optimization Decision of CFRP Processing Parameters Considering Cutting Energy Consumption and Surface Quality [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(10): 1834-1844.
[12]	XU Chengyu, ZHANG Wanyi, ZHANG Tianhong, ZHU Yongwei. Experimental Study of Figuring and Polishing of Titanium Alloy Blades with Fixed Abrasive Tools [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(09): 1606-1612.
[13]	TIAN Tao1, 3, LI Wenhui2, 3, 4, WEN Xuejie1, 3, LI Xiuhong1, 3, YANG Shengqiang1, 3. DEM-FEM Coupled Simulation and Experimental Study of Residual Stresses in Horizontal Vibratory Finishing Processes [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(09): 1667-1676.
[14]	JIN Qichao1, 2, BAO Huzi1, LI Liangwan3, WANG Wenhu3, ZHANG Jinqi1, YE Ziyin1, GUO Lei1. Research on Influences of Surface Roughness and Hardening Rate on Fatigue Property in DD5 Creep Feed Grinding [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(08): 1472-1479.
[15]	DONG Zhibo1, LI Chengkun1, WANG Chengcheng1, HAN Fang1, ZHANG Zhihang1, TENG Junfei2, LYU Yanlong2. Study on Influence Rules of Residual Stress on Thermal Fatigue Life of GH3230 Laminate Welds [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(06): 1097-1102.