An Improved Tool Point Frequency Response Function Prediction Method Based on RCSA

Abstract

Abstract:

The present predicting methods of tool point frequency response function (FRF) based on RCSA needed to identify the joint parameters of the spindle-holder and holder-tool joints and to manufacture the artificial tool-holder model, which will result in predicting errors and complexity, aiming at these problems, this paper presented an improved tool point FRF predicting method based on the RCSA. This method firstly improved the present substructure separating methods, and separated the machine-spindle-holder-tool structure into three parts: the machine-spindle-holder-partial tool bar, the remaining toolbar and the tool tooth; then improved the method for calculating the rotating FRFs of the machine-spindle-holder-partial tool bar through inverse RCSA and finite difference method by applying modal impact test on the toolbar, and calculated the FRFs of the remaining toolbar and tool tooth using Euler beam theory;finally the tool point FRF was predicted by coupling the three parts' FRFs. Experiments conducted on a machining center show that the predicted and measured tool point FRFs are in good agreement, the error between the first three order natural frequencies of the predicted and measured FRFs are within 6.9%, the proposed method is feasible, effective and easy to carry out, it can compute the spindle-holder's rotating FRFs directly based on the tool modal experiments, avoiding the identification of the joint parameters and the manufacturing of the holder model.

Key words: milling cutter, tool point frequency response function, prediction, receptance coupling substructure analysis (RCSA)

摘要：

针对现有的基于响应耦合子结构法(RCSA)的刀尖点频响函数预测方法需要辨识主轴-刀柄、刀柄-刀具结合面参数以及需要自制刀柄模型等引起的预测误差和预测过程复杂等问题，提出一种改进的基于RCSA的铣刀刀尖点频响函数预测方法。该方法首先改进已有的子结构划分方法，将机床-主轴-刀柄-刀具系统划分为机床-主轴-刀柄-部分刀杆、剩余刀杆和刀齿三个子结构;然后改进主轴-刀柄处转动频响函数的计算方法，通过铣刀的模态锤击实验采用反向RCSA和有限差分法计算机床-主轴-刀柄-部分刀杆结构的转动频响函数，并基于Euler梁模型计算出剩余刀杆、刀齿子结构的频响函数;最后将三个子结构的频响函数耦合确定刀尖点的预测频响函数。以一立式加工中心为研究对象，应用所提出的方法对铣刀刀尖点的频响函数进行了预测，并与其实测频响函数进行对比。对比结果表明：刀尖点的预测频响函数与实测频响函数符合程度较高，其预测、实测前三阶固有频率之间的误差在6.9%以内，所提出的方法可行有效、简单方便，且可直接基于铣刀的模态实验计算主轴-刀柄的频响函数，避免了相关结合面参数的辨识和刀柄模型的制作。

关键词: 铣刀, 刀尖点频响函数, 预测, 响应耦合子结构法

CLC Number:

TH113

Zhu Jianmin, Wang Jian, Zhang Tongchao, Li Xiaoru. An Improved Tool Point Frequency Response Function Prediction Method Based on RCSA[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2015, 26(3): 285-292.

朱坚民, 王健, 张统超, 李孝茹. 一种改进的基于响应耦合子结构法的刀尖点频响函数预测方法[J]. 中国机械工程, 2015, 26(3): 285-292.

References

[1]Altintas Y，Budak E．Analytical Prediction of Stability Lobes in Milling[J]．CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology，1995，44 (1)：357-362.
[2]Altintas Y．Analytical Prediction of Three Dimensional Chatter Stability in Milling[J]．JSME International Journal，2001，44(3)：717-723.
[3]Schmitz T L，Donalson R R．Predicting High-speed Machining Dynamics by Substructure Analysis[J]．CIRP Annals Manufacturing Technology，2000，49 (1)：303-308．
[4]Schmitz T L，Davies M A，Kennedy M D. Tool Point Frequency Responseprediction for High-speed Machining by RCSA[J].Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering，2001，123 (4)：700-707．
[5]Schmitz T，Duncan G．Three-component Receptance Coupling Substructure Analysis for Tool Point Dynamics Prediction[J]. Transactions of the ASME. B: Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering，2005，127(4)：781-790．
[6]Kivanc E B，Budak E．Structural Modeling of End Mills for form Error Andstability Analysis[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2004，44(11)：1151-1161．
[7]Ertürk A，zgüven H N，Budak E．Analytical Modelling of Spindle–tooldynamics on Machine Tools Using Timoshenko Beam Model and Receptance Coupling for the Prediction of Tool Point FRF[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2006，46(15)：1901-1912．
[8]Filiz S，Cheng C H，PowellK B，et al．An Improved Tool Holder Model for RCSA Tool-point Frequency Response Prediction[J]．Precision Engineering，2009，33(1)：26-36．
[9]Schmitz T L，Powell K，Won D，et al．Shrink Fit Tool Holder Connection Stiffness/Damping Modelling for Frequency Response Prediction in Milling[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2007，47(9)：1368-1380．
[10]Kumar U V，Schmitz T L．Spindle Dynamics Identification for Receptance Coupling Substructure Analysis[J]．Precision Engineering，2012，36(3):435-443．
[11]Namazi M，Altintas Y，Abe T，et al．Modeling and Identification of Tool Holder-spindle Interface Dynamics[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 2007, 47(9): 1333-1341.
[12]Ertürk A，zgüven H N，Budak E．Effect Analysis of Bearing and Interface Dynamics on Tool Point FRF for Chatter Stability in Machine Tools by Using a New Analytical Model for Spindle-tool Assemblies[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2007，47(1)：23-32．
[13]闫蓉，蔡飞飞，彭芳瑜，等．基于响应耦合方法的铣刀刀尖点频响函数预测[J]．华中科技大学学报(自然科学版)，2013，41(4)：1-6.
Yan Rong, Cai Feifei, Peng Fangyu, et al. Tool Point Dynamic Prediction Based on Receptance Coupling Analysis[J]. Huazhong University of Science&Technology(Natural Science Edition)，2013，41(4)：1-6.
[14]Mohammad R M，Javad M.Prediction of Spindle Dynamics in Mill by Sub-strcture Coupling[J]. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 2006, 46(3/4):243-251.
[15]王二化，吴波，胡友民，等．主轴-刀柄与刀柄-刀具结合面参数辨识研究[J].振动与冲击，2014，33(10)：50-54．
Wang Erhua, Wu Bo, Hu Youmin，et al. Identification of Spindle-handle and Handle-tool Joint Parameters[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2014, 33(10): 50-54．
[16]Park S S，Altintas Y，Movahhedy M. Receptance Coupling for End Mills[J].International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2003, 43(9): 889-896．
[17]Mancisidor I，Urkiola A，Barcena R，et al．Receptance Coupling for Tool Point Dynamic Prediction by Fixed Boundaries Approach[J]．International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture，2014，78(1)：18-29．
[18]Blevins R，Plunkett R．Formulas for Natural Frequency and Mode Shape[J]．Journal of Applied Mechanics，1980，47(2)：461-462．
[19]俞科斌，李郝林，陈吉勇. 圆盘剪刀轴有限元分析及优化设计[J]. 上海理工大学学报，2014，36(1):39-43.
Yu Kebin, Li Haolin, Chen Jiyong. Finite Analysisand Optimization Design of Knife Shaft for Side Trimmer[J].Journal of Shanghai University of Science and Technology, 2014, 36(1):39-43.
[20]李胡生，张雷，林立，等. 考虑刚度及铰支边界条件的短索索力求解方法[J]. 上海理工大学学报，2010，32(6):519-524.
Li Husheng, Zhang Lei, Lin Li, et al. Solving Methodfor Short Cable Tension in Considerationof Cable Stiffness and Simply Supported Boundary Condition[J].Journal of Shanghai University of Science and Technology, 2010, 32(6):519-524.
[21]Duarte M，Ewins D．Rotational Degrees of Freedom for Structural Coupling Analysis Via Finite-difference Technique with Residual Compensation[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing，2000，14(2):205-227．