一种针对圆形设计容差的二元测量系统能力评价的新方法

中国机械工程 ›› 2015, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (9): 1200-1204.

一种针对圆形设计容差的二元测量系统能力评价的新方法

吴小芳;何桢;施亮星

天津大学,天津,300072

出版日期:2015-05-10 发布日期:2015-05-08
基金资助:
国家杰出青年科学基金资助项目（71225006）；国家自然科学基金资助项目（71102140）;国家自然科学基金资助重点项目（70931004）

A New Method of Evaluating Measurement System Capability for Two-dimensional Data with Circular Design Tolerances

Wu Xiaofang;He Zhen;Shi Liangxing

Tianjin University,Tianjin,300072

Online:2015-05-10 Published:2015-05-08
Supported by:
National Science Funds for Distinguished Young Scholars( No. 71225006);National Natural Science Foundation of China（No. 71102140, 70931004）

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

在一些测量过程中,测量仪器测得的数据是二维的,且设计容差为一个圆,当二元被测质量特性具有相关性时,无法直接利用常用的一元测量系统能力评价指数对圆形设计容差的二元测量系统进行分析和评价。提出了一种基于面积之比构造评价指数的方法,利用测量误差椭圆面积与设计容差圆面积之比和测量误差与测量值的椭圆面积之比建立测量系统能力评价指数,将常见的一元测量系统能力指数延伸到二元测量系统中,通过多元方差分析(MANOVA)估计评价指数来评价二元测量系统的能力。通过实例对该方法进行了验证。

关键词: 测量系统能力, 二维数据, 重复性与再现性, 多元方差分析

Abstract:

In some measurement processes the measured data by a gauge are two-dimensional and the design tolerance is a circular. When there is some correlation between two measured quality characteristics, the common evaluation indices for univariate measurement system capability cannot be applied directly to analyze and evaluate the two-dimensional measurement system capability with circular tolerance. A method of constructing evaluation indices based on ratios of areas was proposed herein. The measurement system capability evaluation indices were built through the area ratio of ellipse of gauge errors and circular of design tolerance, the ellipse area ratio of gauge error and measured values. Then the common evaluation indices for univariate measurement system capability could be extended to the two-dimensional measurement system. MANOVA was used to estimate the indices to assess the two-dimensional measurement system capability. At last the proposed method was proved by an example.

Key words: measurement system capability;two-dimensional data;repeatability and reproducibility(R&R);multivariate analysis of , variance(MANOVA)

中图分类号:

N945.16

吴小芳, 何桢, 施亮星. 一种针对圆形设计容差的二元测量系统能力评价的新方法[J]. 中国机械工程, 2015, 26(9): 1200-1204.

Wu Xiaofang, He Zhen, Shi Liangxing. A New Method of Evaluating Measurement System Capability for Two-dimensional Data with Circular Design Tolerances[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2015, 26(9): 1200-1204.

参考文献

[1]Burdick R K,Borror C M,Montgomery D C.Design and Analysis of Gauge R&R Studies[M].Philadelphia,PA:ASA-SIAM,2005.
[2]何桢,董延峰,张敏.方差分析在复杂测量系统能力分析中的应用[J].数理统计与管理,2006,25(4):386-391.
He Zhen,Dong Yanfeng,Zhang Min.A Study on Complicated Measurement System Analysis[J].Application of Statistics and Management, 2006,25(4):386-391.
[3]储晓承,叶文华,俞晖,等.基于正态模糊化方法的在机测量系统性能模糊综合评判[J].中国机械工程,2010,21(20):2424-2429.
Chu Xiaocheng,Ye Wenhua,Yu Hui,et al.Fuzzy Evaluation for Performance of On-machine Inspect System Using Normal Distribution Fuzzification Method[J].China Mechanical Engineering,2010,21(20):2424-2429.
[4]Burdick R K,Borror C M,Montgomery D C.A Review of Methods for Measurement Systems Capability Analysis[J].Journal of Quality Technology,2003,35:342-354.
[5]Li M H C,Al-Refaie A.Improving Wooden Parts’ Quality by Adopting DMAIC Procedure[J].Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 2008,24:351-360.
[6]Woodall W H,Borror C M.Some Relationships between Gage R&R Criteria[J].Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 2008,24:99-106.
[7]Erdmann T P,Does R J,Bisgaard S.Quality Quandaries:a Gauge R&R Study in a Hospital[J].Quality Engineering,2010,22:46-53.
[8]Nachtsheim C J,Becker K E.When is R2 Appropriate for Comparing Customer and Supplier Measurement Systems[J].Quality and Reliability Engineering International,2011,27:1025-1031.
[9]Deldossi L,Zappa D.Confidence Intervals for Variance Components in Measurement System Capability Studies[J]. Communications in Statistics-Theory and Methods,2012,41:2932-2943.
[10]Majeske K D.Approval Criteria for Multivariate Measurement Systems[J].Journal of Quality Technology,2008,40(2):140-153.
[11]吴小芳, 何桢, 施亮星. 基于向量的多元测量系统能力评价指数[J].系统工程,2013,31(3):123-126.
Wu Xiaofang, He Zhen,Shi Liangxing.Multivariate Measurement System Capability Indices Based on Vector[J]. Systems Engineering, 2013,31(3):123-126.
[12]Wang F K,Chien T W.Process-oriented Basis Representation for a Multivariate Gauge Study[J].Computers and Industrial Engineering,2010,58:143-150.
[13]Wang F K,Yang C W.Applying Principal Component Analysis to a GR&R Study[J].Journal of the Chinese Institute of Industrial Engineering,2007,24:182-189.
[14]Peruchi R S, Balestrassi P P, et al.A New Multivariate Gauge R&R Method for Correlated Characteristics[J].International Journal of Production Economics, 2013, 144: 301-315.
[15]Voelkel J G.Gauge R&R Analysis for Two-dimensional Data with Circular Tolerances[J].Journal of Quality Technology, 2003, 35(2): 153-167.
[16]Shannon S. Analysis of Two-dimensional Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility [J]. Quality Engineering, 2007, 19:29-37.
[17]Wang F K,Chern H L.Confidence Intervals for Two-dimensional Data with Circular Tolerance in a Gauge R&R Study[J]. Quality & Quantity,2012,46:55-59.
[18]Automotive Industry Action Group.Measurement Systems Analysis[M].4th ed.Betroit:Automotive Industry Action Group,2010.
[19]Montgomery D C,Runger G C.Gauge Capability and Designed Experiments,Part I:Basic Methods[J].Quality Engineering, 1993, 6: 115-135.
[20]Hubele N F,Shahriari H,Cheng C S.A Bivariate Process Capability Vector [J].Statistical Process Control in Manufacturing, 1991, 3:299-310.
[21]Ch’ng C K,Quah S H,Low H C.Index in Multiple Response Optimization[J].Quality Engineering,2005,17:165-171.